What is Value Investing?
Value investing is a strategy of buying stocks that trade below their intrinsic value—what the underlying business is actually worth. Value investors believe the market sometimes misprices stocks due to emotional reactions, short-term thinking, or neglect, creating opportunities to buy great businesses at discounted prices.
Price is what you pay. Value is what you get.— Warren Buffett
The strategy was pioneered by Benjamin Graham in the 1930s and refined by his most famous student, Warren Buffett, into one of the most successful investment approaches in history.
The Core Idea
Imagine a stock trading at $50 per share. If careful analysis reveals the business is actually worth $80 per share, a value investor sees a 60% upside opportunity. They buy at $50 and wait patiently for the market to eventually recognize the true value.
Benjamin Graham
1894-1976 • Father of Value Investing
"The margin of safety is always dependent on the price paid."
Deep value, statistical analysis, asset-based valuation
Warren Buffett
1930-present • Oracle of Omaha
"It's far better to buy a wonderful company at a fair price than a fair company at a wonderful price."
Quality at reasonable prices, competitive moats, long-term compounding
Core Principles of Value Investing
1. Mr. Market
Graham's famous allegory describes the market as an emotional business partner named "Mr. Market" who offers to buy or sell shares every day. Sometimes his prices are reasonable; other times they're irrationally high or low. Value investors use his mood swings rather than being controlled by them.
2. Intrinsic Value
Every business has an intrinsic value based on its assets, earnings power, and growth potential. This value exists independently of the stock price. The goal is to calculate what a business is truly worth, then wait for opportunities to buy below that value.
3. Margin of Safety
Never pay full price—always demand a significant discount to protect against errors in analysis or unforeseen problems. If you calculate intrinsic value at $100, only buy at $67 or less (33% margin of safety).
4. Long-Term Perspective
Value investing requires patience. The market may take months or years to recognize true value. Short-term price movements are noise; long-term fundamentals are signal.
Early Buffett followed Graham's "cigar butt" approach—buying mediocre businesses very cheaply. Later, influenced by Charlie Munger, he shifted to buying wonderful businesses at fair prices, holding them forever. Both approaches are valid forms of value investing.
Key Valuation Metrics
Value investors use several financial ratios to identify potentially undervalued stocks:
P/E Ratio
Price / EPSHow much you pay per dollar of earnings. Lower = potentially cheaper. Look for P/E below 15.
P/B Ratio
Price / Book ValuePrice relative to net assets. Below 1.0 means trading below liquidation value.
P/FCF Ratio
Price / Free Cash FlowBased on actual cash generation. More reliable than earnings for capital-heavy businesses.
PEG Ratio
P/E / Growth RateAdjusts P/E for growth. PEG below 1.0 suggests undervalued relative to growth.
Dividend Yield
Dividend / PriceCash return while you wait. Higher yields may signal undervaluation or distress.
EV/EBITDA
Enterprise Value / EBITDAValues entire business including debt. Good for comparing across capital structures.
Graham's Original Criteria
Benjamin Graham recommended these specific screens for defensive investors:
- P/E ratio below 15
- Price-to-book ratio below 1.5
- P/E × P/B below 22.5
- Positive earnings for past 10 years
- Dividend payments for past 20 years
- Earnings growth of at least 33% over 10 years
- Current ratio above 2.0 (current assets / current liabilities)
- Long-term debt less than net current assets
Calculating Intrinsic Value
There are several methods to estimate intrinsic value. No method is perfect—use multiple approaches and triangulate.
1. Discounted Cash Flow (DCF)
Project future cash flows and discount them back to present value. The most theoretically correct but also most sensitive to assumptions.
- Estimate free cash flow for next 5-10 years
- Calculate terminal value (value beyond projection period)
- Discount all cash flows at an appropriate rate (often 10-15%)
- Sum discounted values = intrinsic value
2. Graham's Formula
A simplified formula for intrinsic value:
V = EPS × (8.5 + 2g)
Where V = intrinsic value, EPS = earnings per share, g = expected growth rate. For example, a company with $5 EPS and 7% expected growth: V = $5 × (8.5 + 14) = $112.50
3. Asset-Based Valuation
Calculate what the company would be worth if liquidated:
- Net Current Asset Value (NCAV) = Current Assets - Total Liabilities
- Graham's "net-net" stocks trade below NCAV per share
- Most useful for distressed or asset-heavy companies
4. Earnings Power Value (EPV)
Value based on current sustainable earnings:
- Normalize earnings (adjust for one-time items)
- Divide by cost of capital (e.g., 10%)
- EPV = Normalized Earnings / Required Return
- If $100M earnings / 10% = $1B intrinsic value
Margin of Safety
The margin of safety is the most important concept in value investing. It protects you from:
- Analytical errors: Your intrinsic value calculation might be wrong
- Unforeseen problems: Business conditions can deteriorate
- Bad luck: Even good analysis can have bad outcomes
Margin of Safety Illustrated
How Much Margin Do You Need?
- High quality, stable businesses: 20-25% margin may be sufficient
- Cyclical or uncertain businesses: 30-40% margin recommended
- Turnarounds or distressed: 50%+ margin for the added risk
Confronted with a challenge to distill the secret of sound investment into three words, we venture the motto: MARGIN OF SAFETY.— Benjamin Graham, The Intelligent Investor
Avoiding Value Traps
A value trap is a stock that looks cheap but deserves to be cheap. The low valuation reflects fundamental problems, not temporary mispricing. Here's how to avoid them:
- Declining industry: Newspapers, traditional retail, coal—cheap for a reason
- Technological disruption: Business model being obsoleted
- Deteriorating fundamentals: Shrinking margins, losing market share
- High debt loads: Can't invest in the business or survive downturns
- Poor capital allocation: Management destroying value with bad acquisitions
- Accounting red flags: Aggressive revenue recognition, growing receivables
- Dividend cuts: Often signal deeper problems
Value Investing Quality Checklist
Frequently Asked Questions
Value investing is buying stocks that trade below their intrinsic value—what the business is actually worth based on its assets, earnings, and growth potential. Value investors seek companies the market has underpriced due to temporary problems, neglect, or pessimism, then hold patiently until the market recognizes the true value.
Traditional value investors look for P/E ratios below 15, with some seeking ratios under 10 for deep value opportunities. However, P/E should always be compared to industry averages, growth rates, and historical norms. A low P/E alone doesn't make a stock undervalued—it could signal fundamental problems. Quality matters as much as cheapness.
Margin of safety means buying stocks at a significant discount to intrinsic value to protect against errors in analysis or unforeseen problems. Benjamin Graham recommended at least a 33% margin—if you calculate intrinsic value at $100, only buy at $67 or less. This cushion protects your downside while still capturing upside when the market eventually recognizes true value.
Value investing significantly underperformed growth stocks from 2010-2020, leading some to question its effectiveness. However, value has historically worked over long periods and tends to outperform after periods of underperformance (mean reversion). The strategy requires patience and discipline through market cycles. Many argue value's recent struggles make current valuations more attractive.
Value investors buy established companies trading at low multiples relative to current earnings or assets. Growth investors buy companies with high expected future growth, often paying premium multiples. In practice, the best approach may be "growth at a reasonable price" (GARP)—finding quality companies with good growth prospects that aren't overvalued.
Track Your Value Investments
AllInvestView helps you monitor P/E ratios, dividend yields, and other key metrics across your portfolio to identify value opportunities.
Start Tracking Free