Investing strategies · updated October 2026

Value investing: buying a stock for less than the business is worth

Value investing means estimating what a company is worth from its earnings, assets and cash, and buying only when the share price is well below that. The gap is your margin of safety. Cheap on paper isn't enough, though: on 3 November 2022 Meta and Walgreens both traded at under 9 times earnings. One rose about seven-fold; the other was taken private for less than a third of that day's price.

Two cheap stocks, the same dayClosing prices on 3 November 2022, last 12 months of results
Meta Platforms
$88.91 a share
P/E8.5
P/B1.9
Cash yield11%
$10,000 then, on 26 Oct 2026, price alone$70,900
Walgreens Boots Alliance
$35.74 a share
P/E7.1
P/B1.2
Dividend5.4%
Taken private at $11.45 cash, Aug 2025, dividends included$4,160

Walgreens looked cheaper on earnings and book value. The difference was the business: Meta's profits more than doubled by 2024, while Walgreens' turned into losses. Value investing is about finding that difference before the price does.

Intrinsic value calculator

Enter a stock's price and its per-share figures from the latest annual or last-12-month results. You get a discounted cash flow value, the Graham number, the usual ratios and your margin of safety. Start with one of the two examples.

The stock

$
$
$
$
Free cash flow is cash from operations minus capital spending, divided by the number of shares. Book value is shareholders' equity per share.

Your assumptions

%
%
%
The discount rate is the yearly return you want for the risk, often 8% to 12% for a single stock. Growth after year 5 runs forever, so keep it near long-run inflation and below the discount rate.
Value, cash flow$136.66price 35% below it
Graham number$105.11price 15% below it
Share price$88.91Meta in November 2022
Cash flow value per share by discount rate (rows) and growth after year 5 (columns)
Rate \ after

The cash flow value grows today's free cash flow per share for five years, adds a terminal value for the years after, and discounts both back at your rate, the same method as the DCF on our stock pages. It's an estimate built on your assumptions: change the growth or the rate by a point and the value moves a lot, which is why value investors insist on a wide gap. Meta's figures are from its third-quarter 2022 report, Walgreens' from its fiscal 2022 annual report.

The measures value investors use

Each ratio compares the price with one thing the business produces or owns. None works alone; together they show whether a low price is a bargain or a warning. Here they are on the two stocks from November 2022.

Earnings

Price to earnings (P/E)

price ÷ earnings per share

How many years of today's profit you pay for. Misleads when earnings are about to fall or include one-off gains. See the P/E ratio.

Meta8.5
Walgreens7.1
Assets

Price to book (P/B)

price ÷ book value per share

The price against the net assets on the balance sheet. Says little about brands, software and goodwill-heavy companies. See price to book.

Meta1.9
Walgreens1.2
Cash

Free cash flow yield

free cash flow per share ÷ price

The cash the business actually generated, as a yield on the price. The hardest to flatter, and where the two stocks split apart.

Meta11.0%
Walgreens7.0%
Income

Dividend yield

yearly dividend ÷ price

Cash paid to you while you wait. A very high yield often means the market expects a cut. See dividend yield.

MetaNone
Walgreens5.4%
Graham's ceiling

Graham number

√(22.5 × EPS × book value per share)

A modern shortcut from Graham's limits of 15 times earnings and 1.5 times book; he applied the 15 to average earnings of the last three years. Ignores growth, debt and cash.

Meta$105
Walgreens$57
The check

Earnings backed by cash

free cash flow ÷ earnings

If reported profit runs well ahead of the cash coming in, find out why before trusting the P/E. Walgreens' cash covered half its earnings.

Meta93%
Walgreens50%

Per-share figures: Meta, the four quarters to 30 September 2022 (diluted earnings $10.49, free cash flow $26.3 billion over 2,687 million diluted shares, equity $124.1 billion on 30 September over 2,652 million shares outstanding); Walgreens, the fiscal year to 31 August 2022 (diluted earnings $5.01, free cash flow $2.2 billion, equity $25.3 billion over 865 million shares, dividend $0.48 a quarter). Prices are the closes on 3 November 2022.

Intrinsic value and the margin of safety

Intrinsic value is what the business is worth to an owner: the cash it will hand over in the future, discounted to today. You can only estimate it, so value investors buy well below their estimate and leave room to be wrong.

Margin of safety

"Confronted with a like challenge to distill the secret of sound investment into three words, we venture the motto, MARGIN OF SAFETY."Benjamin Graham, The Intelligent Investor, chapter 20
  • The sum: (value − price) ÷ value. Value a share at $100, buy at $70, and your margin is 30%.
  • How much: more for businesses whose earnings swing, carry heavy debt or depend on one product; less for steady ones you understand well.
  • On the examples: at a 10% discount rate, 3% growth for five years and 2.5% after that, Meta's cash flow value was about $137 against an $88.91 price, a 35% margin. Walgreens' was about $35 against $35.74: no margin at all, despite the low P/E.

Three ways to estimate value

  • Discounted cash flow: forecast free cash flow, discount it at the return you need, add a value for the years after the forecast. The most complete method and the most sensitive to your inputs. The calculator above uses it.
  • Earnings and assets: the Graham number, or a fair P/E applied to normal, not peak, earnings. Quick, and a good first screen.
  • Assets alone: what the company would be worth broken up. Graham's "net-net" stocks traded below current assets minus all liabilities; useful for troubled companies, rare among large ones today.

Graham's checklist and Buffett's change of course

Benjamin Graham set out the method in Security Analysis (1934) and The Intelligent Investor (1949). His tests for a defensive investor buying individual stocks, from the 1973 edition:

  • Adequate sizeLarge, established companies only, to avoid the extra risk of small ones.
  • Strong financesFor industrial companies, current assets at least twice current liabilities and long-term debt no more than net current assets. For utilities, debt no more than twice equity.
  • Steady earningsSome profit in each of the past ten years.
  • Dividend recordDividends paid without a break for at least 20 years.
  • Earnings growthEarnings per share up at least a third over ten years, comparing three-year averages at each end.
  • Moderate priceNo more than 15 times average earnings of the last three years, and no more than 1.5 times book value, or P/E times P/B below 22.5.

Mr. Market

Graham's picture of the stock market as a moody business partner who offers every day to buy your share or sell you his, at prices that swing with his mood. You don't have to trade with him. His bad days are when a value investor buys, as plenty did with Meta in late 2022.

Wonderful company, fair price

"It's far better to buy a wonderful company at a fair price than a fair company at a wonderful price."Warren Buffett, Berkshire Hathaway letter to shareholders, 1989

Buffett started with Graham's very cheap, ordinary businesses and, with Charlie Munger, moved towards durable businesses bought at sensible prices and held for years. Both are value investing: paying less than the business is worth.

Value traps: when cheap gets cheaper

A value trap looks cheap because its past figures are good, while the business behind them is getting worse. Walgreens from November 2022 is a clear case: at $35.74, $10,000 bought about 280 shares.

  1. Nov 2022

    Cheap on earnings and assets

    P/E 7.1, a 5.4% dividend and the price 38% below its Graham number.

  2. Jan 2023

    A quarterly loss

    The quarter to November closed at a loss of $4.31 a share, mostly opioid litigation charges.

  3. Jan 2024

    Dividend cut

    The quarterly dividend fell from $0.48 to $0.25. Fiscal 2024 ended with a loss of $10.01 a share.

  4. Jan 2025

    Dividend suspended

    The company stopped paying a dividend to keep cash for its turnaround.

  5. Aug 2025

    Taken private

    Sycamore Partners paid $11.45 a share in cash, plus a right to up to $3 more from the sale of VillageMD.

What the $10,000 became

  • $3,204 in buyout cash for 279.8 shares at $11.45.
  • $951 in dividends along the way: five at $0.48 and four at $0.25, $3.40 a share.
  • About $4,160 in all, a loss of 58%, before anything paid on the VillageMD right. The same $10,000 in Meta was worth about $70,900 on 26 October 2026.

Warning signs to check

  • Profits not backed by cash: free cash flow far below earnings, or earnings lifted by asset sales.
  • A shrinking or disrupted business: falling sales or margins, customers moving elsewhere.
  • Rising debt or big legal bills eating into what's left for shareholders.
  • A yield the cash can't cover: dividends close to or above free cash flow.
  • Cheap for years while the earnings slide: a low P/E on falling profits is not a bargain.

Does value investing still work? Value vs growth since 2005

Cheap stocks as a group have had a long, hard stretch. Each bar is how far Vanguard's Value ETF (VTV) finished ahead of, or behind, its Growth ETF (VUG) in a calendar year, dividends reinvested. For which style suits you, see growth vs value investing.

$10,000 in value$73,400VTV, Jan 2005 to Oct 2026
$10,000 in growth$128,700VUG, same dates
Value years ahead6 of 21Full years 2005 to 2025
+2
2005: value 7.2%, growth 5.0%
+13
2006: value 22.4%, growth 9.2%
-13
2007: value -0.1%, growth 12.5%
+2
2008: value -35.9%, growth -38.0%
-16
2009: value 19.9%, growth 36.1%
-3
2010: value 14.5%, growth 17.2%
-1
2011: value 1.1%, growth 1.8%
-2
2012: value 15.2%, growth 17.0%
+1
2013: value 33.1%, growth 32.5%
0
2014: value 13.2%, growth 13.6%
-4
2015: value -1.0%, growth 3.2%
+11
2016: value 17.1%, growth 6.3%
-11
2017: value 17.1%, growth 27.7%
-2
2018: value -5.5%, growth -3.3%
-11
2019: value 25.7%, growth 37.0%
-38
2020: value 2.3%, growth 40.2%
-1
2021: value 26.5%, growth 27.3%
+31
2022: value -2.1%, growth -33.2%
-38
2023: value 9.3%, growth 46.8%
-17
2024: value 16.0%, growth 32.7%
-4
2025: value 15.3%, growth 19.4%
+12
2026 to 26 Oct: value 20.3%, growth 8.0%
Value ahead (points)Growth ahead (points)* 2026 to 26 October

What the bars show

  • Growth won 12 of the 15 years from 2007 to 2021, led by the large tech companies; in 2020 it beat value by 38 points.
  • Value held up in 2022, losing 2.1% while growth lost 33.2%, and is ahead again in 2026 so far: 20.3% against 8.0%.
  • Over longer periods the research favours cheap stocks. Eugene Fama and Kenneth French found that US stocks with a high book value relative to price earned higher average returns from 1963 to 1990.

A value fund or your own picks

A value index fund holds the stocks that score cheapest on a set of ratios; VTV follows the CRSP US Large Cap Value Index. So it owns mostly big companies at lower multiples, not deep bargains, and it doesn't judge whether a business is getting better or worse. Picking your own stocks is where the business analysis above comes in, along with the risk of being wrong on a few names. Many investors hold a value fund as the core and a handful of researched picks around it.

Total returns from adjusted closing prices; 26 October 2026 is the last close used. Past returns don't tell you what either style will do next.

How to start value investing

Four steps, from finding a candidate to knowing when you were wrong.

  1. Find cheap candidates

    Start from stocks with low P/E or P/B ratios, such as our lowest P/E stocks, or from companies you know whose price has fallen hard.

  2. Read the business

    Ten years of earnings, debt against assets, and free cash flow against profit. Ask why it's cheap and whether that reason will last. If you can't explain it, skip it.

  3. Value it and set a price

    Estimate a value with the calculator or the DCF on the stock's page, then decide your buy price with a margin of safety, say 25% to 40% below.

  4. Buy, track and re-check

    Write down why you bought. Re-check the case with each annual report; sell when the price passes your value or the reason no longer holds.

The numbers on every stock page

AllInvestView's stock pages show the price with P/E, forward P/E, book value and price to book. Signed in, you can run a DCF on the stock and change its growth, capital spending, tax, terminal growth and cost of capital.

AllInvestView stock page DCF valuation: model fair value against the price, the assumptions, and a table of fair value by discount rate and terminal growth
The DCF result on Meta's stock page: the model's fair value against the price, fair value by discount rate and terminal growth, and the cash flows behind it.

From a valuation to a position you can follow

Once you buy, add the holding or link your broker. Your return, dividends and cost basis stay up to date across all your accounts, so you can see whether the price is moving towards your value.

The DCF uses the same method as the calculator above: projected free cash flow and a terminal value, discounted to today.

Value investing questions

What is value investing in simple terms?

Buying shares for less than you think the business is worth, and waiting for the price to catch up. You estimate the value from what the company earns, owns and pays out in cash, compare it with the share price, and only buy when there's a clear gap, the margin of safety, to cover the chance you're wrong.

Does value investing still work?

It has gone through long dry spells. Measured by Vanguard's Value and Growth ETFs, growth stocks returned far more from 2005 to 2025, with value ahead in only six of those 21 calendar years. Value held up much better in 2022, when value lost 2.1% and growth lost 33.2%, and it is ahead again in 2026 so far (20.3% against 8.0% to 26 October). Picking individual stocks well is a different question from whether a cheap-stock index beats the market.

What is a good P/E ratio for a value stock?

There's no single number. Benjamin Graham's test for a defensive investor was no more than 15 times average earnings over the past three years. A low P/E only means the price is low against last year's profit: Walgreens had a P/E of about 7 in November 2022 and its earnings then turned into large losses. Check whether the earnings are steady and backed by cash before trusting the ratio.

What is the margin of safety?

The gap between what you think a share is worth and the price you pay. If you value a stock at $100 and buy at $70, your margin of safety is 30%. Graham called it the central idea of sound investing because it leaves room for mistakes in your estimate and for bad luck in the business.

What is the Graham number?

A rough ceiling on what a defensive investor should pay: the square root of 22.5 times earnings per share times book value per share. The 22.5 comes from Graham's limits of 15 times earnings (he used the average of the last three years) and 1.5 times book value; the formula is a later shortcut built from them. It ignores growth, debt and cash flow, so it's a first screen, not a valuation.

What is a value trap?

A stock that looks cheap on its ratios but keeps falling because the business is getting worse. The earnings behind the low P/E shrink or turn into losses, the dividend is cut, and the price never catches up. Falling sales, rising debt, profits that aren't backed by cash and a high yield the company can't afford are the usual signs.

Is Warren Buffett a value investor?

Yes, though not in Graham's original style. He began by buying very cheap, ordinary businesses, then moved towards buying excellent ones at fair prices, as he put it in Berkshire Hathaway's 1989 letter: "It's far better to buy a wonderful company at a fair price than a fair company at a wonderful price."

Follow your value picks in one place

Link your brokers or import your trades. AllInvestView keeps each holding's return, dividends and cost basis right across all your accounts and currencies.

Create a free account

Related guides and tools

Sources

  • Meta Platforms: Form 10-Q for the third quarter of 2022 and Form 10-K for 2021, 2024 and 2025 (SEC EDGAR)
  • Walgreens Boots Alliance: Form 10-K for fiscal 2022, 2023 and 2024 (SEC EDGAR); dividend and quarterly results announcements; Sycamore Partners' completion of the acquisition, 28 August 2025
  • Benjamin Graham, The Intelligent Investor, revised edition 1973 (chapters 8, 14 and 20). Warren Buffett, Berkshire Hathaway 1989 letter to shareholders
  • Eugene Fama and Kenneth French, "The Cross-Section of Expected Stock Returns", Journal of Finance, 1992
  • Fund returns: Vanguard Value ETF (VTV) and Vanguard Growth ETF (VUG), calendar-year total returns from adjusted closing prices

Prices are official closing prices on the dates shown. Checked on 27 October 2026. This page explains value investing in general terms and isn't advice to buy or sell any stock.