Model portfolio, tested on real prices

Golden Butterfly Portfolio: Allocation, ETFs and Returns

The Golden Butterfly puts 20% each into five things: the whole US stock market, US small-cap value stocks, long-term Treasuries, short-term Treasuries and gold. You rebalance back to 20% once a year.

Built with five ETFs, $10,000 at the end of 2004 grew to $50,738 by 23 October 2026, 7.7% a year. A 60/40 portfolio made about the same, $53,253, but fell 34.0% at its worst. The Golden Butterfly never fell more than 20.0%.

$10,000 became$50,738end of 2004 to 23 Oct 2026, dividends reinvested
A year7.7%60/40: 8.0%. S&P 500: 10.8%
Worst fall20.0%60/40: 34.0%. S&P 500: 55.2%
In 2008−4.9%S&P 500: −36.8%. Treasuries and gold rose

Golden Butterfly returns since 2005

Five ETFs at 20% each, rebalanced every January, against a 60/40 of S&P 500 and US bonds and the S&P 500 on its own.

  • Golden Butterfly
  • 60/40
  • S&P 500

Month-end values. Move along the chart to read any month.

Dec 2004 to Oct 2026$10,000 becameA yearWorst fallWorst yearYears with a lossBack to its high after 2008
Golden Butterfly$50,7387.7%−20.0%−12.9% (2022)4 of 21Sep 2009
60/40$53,2538.0%−34.0%−19.1% (2008)3 of 21Nov 2010
S&P 500$93,41210.8%−55.2%−36.8% (2008)3 of 21Aug 2012

Year by year

Calendar-year returns with dividends reinvested. 2026 runs to 23 October.

  • Golden Butterfly
  • S&P 500

Why it falls less: the slices take turns

Each slice's own return, year by year. In most years something was up when stocks were down.

2008: bonds and gold carried it

US stocks lost 37.0% and small-cap value 32.2%. Long Treasuries gained 34.0%, short ones 6.6% and gold 4.9%, so the whole portfolio lost only 4.9%.

2013: gold and bonds dragged

Stocks gained 33.4% and small-cap value 36.6%, but gold fell 28.3% and long Treasuries 13.4%. The portfolio made 5.5% while the S&P 500 made 32.3%.

2022: almost nothing worked

Rates jumped and long Treasuries lost 31.2%, worse than stocks. Gold held at −0.8%. The portfolio lost 12.9%, its worst year, and only got back to its old high in March 2024.

Golden Butterfly ETFs for each slice

The funds used in the test, a lower-cost swap for each, and a UCITS version if you buy in Europe. Fees checked 24 October 2026.

Slice (20% each)ETF used hereLower-cost swapUCITS, if you buy in Europe
Total US stocksGrowth from the whole market
VTIVanguard Morningstar Total Stock Market ETF0.03% a year
VTI is already one of the cheapest funds there is.
CSPXiShares Core S&P 500 UCITS ETF (Acc), IE00B5BMR0870.07% a year
Small-cap valueSmaller, cheaper US companies
VBRVanguard Morningstar Small-Cap Value ETF0.05% a year
VBR is already the low-cost choice for this slice.
ZPRVSPDR MSCI USA Small Cap Value Weighted UCITS ETF (Acc), IE00BSPLC4130.30% a year
Long-term TreasuriesRises when rates fall and in most crashes
TLTiShares 20+ Year Treasury Bond ETF0.15% a year
VGLTVanguard Long-Term Treasury ETF0.03% a year
IDTL or DTLAiShares $ Treasury Bond 20+yr UCITS ETF, Dist or Acc0.07% a year
Short-term TreasuriesClose to cash, with a little interest
SHYiShares 1-3 Year Treasury Bond ETF0.15% a year
VGSHVanguard Short-Term Treasury ETF0.03% a year
IBTS or IBTAiShares $ Treasury Bond 1-3yr UCITS ETF, Dist or Acc0.07% a year
GoldHolds up against inflation and panics
GLDSPDR Gold Shares0.40% a year
GLDMSPDR Gold MiniShares0.10% a year
SGLNiShares Physical Gold ETC, IE00B4ND36020.12% a year
Average fee of the five used here: 0.16% a year, or $15.60 on $10,000.With the swaps: 0.05%.

Total US stocks

Used here
VTI, 0.03%Vanguard Morningstar Total Stock Market ETF
Swap
VTI is already one of the cheapest funds there is.
UCITS
CSPX, 0.07%iShares Core S&P 500 UCITS ETF (Acc), IE00B5BMR087

Small-cap value

Used here
VBR, 0.05%Vanguard Morningstar Small-Cap Value ETF
Swap
VBR is already the low-cost choice for this slice.
UCITS
ZPRV, 0.30%SPDR MSCI USA Small Cap Value Weighted UCITS ETF (Acc), IE00BSPLC413

Long-term Treasuries

Used here
TLT, 0.15%iShares 20+ Year Treasury Bond ETF
Swap
VGLT, 0.03%Vanguard Long-Term Treasury ETF
UCITS
IDTL or DTLA, 0.07%iShares $ Treasury Bond 20+yr UCITS ETF, Dist or Acc

Short-term Treasuries

Used here
SHY, 0.15%iShares 1-3 Year Treasury Bond ETF
Swap
VGSH, 0.03%Vanguard Short-Term Treasury ETF
UCITS
IBTS or IBTA, 0.07%iShares $ Treasury Bond 1-3yr UCITS ETF, Dist or Acc

Gold

Used here
GLD, 0.40%SPDR Gold Shares
Swap
GLDM, 0.10%SPDR Gold MiniShares
UCITS
SGLN, 0.12%iShares Physical Gold ETC, IE00B4ND3602

Average fee of the five used here: 0.16% a year, $15.60 on $10,000. With the swaps: 0.05%.

In Europe gold trades as an ETC, not a UCITS ETF, and the S&P 500 fund stands in for the total market. These funds hold US dollar assets, so a euro or pound investor also takes the swings in the exchange rate.

What your money buys

Whole shares of each ETF at the 23 October 2026 close. With fractional shares you can split any amount exactly.

Each slice gets a fifth of the amount. The cash left over is what whole shares can't use up.

ETFPriceSharesCost
Total
Cash left over

Rebalancing the Golden Butterfly once a year

Sell what grew past 20% and buy what fell below it. Here is the real drift from 2026, ready to change to your own numbers.

$10,000 split evenly on 2 January 2026 was worth $10,307 by 23 October. Small-cap value had grown to 22.1% of the portfolio and gold had shrunk to 17.9%. Type in what you hold today.

SliceNowTargetTrade
Total

New money can fill the slices below 20% without selling anything. In a taxable account that saves you realising a gain.

Tracking it across accounts

Five slices, five targets, one view of the drift

AllInvestView holds each slice against its 20% target from live prices, even when the ETFs sit at different brokers or in an IRA and a taxable account. When it's time to rebalance it lists the buys and sells, with or without selling, and can estimate the tax on each sell from your own capital gains rules. Five ETFs fit in the free plan's ten holdings.

Read the rebalancing guide
AllInvestView AllInvestView rebalancing page for a four-ETF demo portfolio. Allocation breakdown: US Stocks 68.0% against a 60% target, Bonds 16.0% against 15%, International Stocks 12.0% against 20%, Real Estate 4.0% against 5%. Recommendations: sell 8,038.87 USD of US Stocks, buy 8,011.73 USD of International Stocks, buy 1,033.12 USD of Real Estate and sell 1,005.97 USD of Bonds, each landing on its target, with an estimated tax of about 528.59 USD and 5.26 USD on the two sells at a 15% long-term rate AllInvestView rebalancing page for a four-ETF demo portfolio. Allocation breakdown: US Stocks 68.0% against a 60% target, Bonds 16.0% against 15%, International Stocks 12.0% against 20%, Real Estate 4.0% against 5%. Recommendations: sell 8,038.87 USD of US Stocks, buy 8,011.73 USD of International Stocks, buy 1,033.12 USD of Real Estate and sell 1,005.97 USD of Bonds, each landing on its target, with an estimated tax of about 528.59 USD and 5.26 USD on the two sells at a 15% long-term rate
The rebalancing page on a four-ETF demo portfolio that drifted to 68/16/12/4 against targets of 60/15/20/5: the drift on each asset class, then the trades that put each one back on target, with the estimated tax on the two sells. Demo portfolio; the allocation and recommendation cards of the same page stacked into one image.View full-size View full-size

Golden Butterfly vs Permanent Portfolio, All Weather and 60/40

The same test for all four: $10,000 on 2 January 2019 to 22 October 2026, rebalanced every January.

What the Golden Butterfly gives up

Four costs that show up when you hold it for years.

It trails in strong stock markets

With only 40% in stocks, it trailed the S&P 500 in 13 of the 21 full years since 2005. Over the whole run that adds up: $50,738 against $93,412. If you can sit through a 55% fall, the stock-heavy route has paid more.

40% in Treasuries means rates matter

When rates jump, long Treasuries fall hard. In 2022 they lost 31.2% and the portfolio took until March 2024 to get back to its high, longer than the S&P 500, which recovered in December 2023.

Gold can go nowhere for years

Gold lost 28.3% in 2013 and fell again in 2014 and 2015, then gained 63.7% in 2025. In a US taxable account, gains on a physical gold ETF like GLD are taxed as collectibles, at up to 28% when held over a year.

Every stock is a US stock

Both stock slices are US-only. If you want companies from the rest of the world, a three-fund portfolio holds them, or you can swap the total-market slice for a world fund.

After you buy it

Track your Golden Butterfly in one place

Sync or import your brokers and AllInvestView shows the five slices against their 20% targets, the return of the whole portfolio, the dividends and interest, and the tax when you sell.

Targets and drift for each slice Every broker in one view Free for up to 10 holdings

Questions about the Golden Butterfly

What is the Golden Butterfly portfolio?

A five-way split published by Tyler at Portfolio Charts as a twist on Harry Browne's Permanent Portfolio: 20% in the US total stock market, 20% in US small-cap value, 20% in long-term Treasuries, 20% in short-term Treasuries and 20% in gold, rebalanced back to 20% each once a year. The idea is that whatever the economy does next, at least one of the five should do well.

Which ETFs make up the Golden Butterfly?

The usual US picks are VTI, VBR, TLT, SHY and GLD, with an average fee of 0.16% a year. VGLT, VGSH and GLDM do the same jobs for less and bring the average down to about 0.05%. In Europe, CSPX, ZPRV, IDTL or DTLA, IBTS or IBTA and a physical gold ETC such as SGLN cover the five slices.

What has the Golden Butterfly returned?

With those five ETFs, $10,000 at the end of 2004 was worth $50,738 on 23 October 2026, 7.7% a year with dividends reinvested and a rebalance every January. Its worst year was 2022, down 12.9%, and its deepest fall from a high was 20.0%, in March 2009.

Is the Golden Butterfly better than a 60/40 portfolio?

From 2005 to 2026 they earned about the same, 7.7% a year against 8.0%. The ride was different. The 60/40 fell 34.0% in 2008 and 2009 and only got back to its high in November 2010; the Golden Butterfly fell 20.0% and was back by September 2009. After 2022 it went the other way: the Golden Butterfly took until March 2024 to recover, the 60/40 until January 2024.

How is it different from the Permanent Portfolio?

The Permanent Portfolio holds 25% each in stocks, long-term Treasuries, gold and cash. The Golden Butterfly trims those to 20%, swaps the cash for short-term Treasuries and adds a second 20% of stocks in small-cap value. From January 2019 to October 2026 it earned 9.3% a year against 8.6%, with a similar worst fall: 18.8% against 17.6%.

How often should you rebalance the Golden Butterfly?

Once a year is enough, and it is what the test on this page does. Others wait until a slice drifts outside a band they set. Either way, putting new money into the slices below 20% first means you sell less, which matters in a taxable account.

Sources and how the numbers were worked out

The test uses daily closing prices in US dollars with dividends and interest reinvested, before tax and with no trading costs; fund fees are already in the prices. $10,000 goes in at the close on 31 December 2004, the first year end after GLD began trading, and each portfolio is rebalanced to its weights on the first trading day of every year. The 60/40 is 60% SPY and 40% AGG; the S&P 500 is SPY. Worst fall is the largest drop from a previous high in daily values. The comparison with the Permanent Portfolio and All Weather uses the shorter 2019 to 2026 test from the portfolio examples page, with the funds listed on each page. Past returns don't tell you future ones, and none of this is a recommendation to buy a particular fund.